CUNY John Jay admits approximately 57.2% of applicants, meaning roughly 3 in 5 applicants receives an offer of admission. This places the institution in the moderately selective category, providing reasonable admission odds for qualified students interested in criminal justice education. The peer median admission rate of 78.1% indicates that CUNY John Jay maintains somewhat higher selectivity standards than typical public institutions. However, this level of selectivity remains accessible for students with solid academic preparation, unlike highly competitive universities where admission becomes unpredictable even for strong candidates. The institution's admission rate reflects its role as a specialized college focusing on criminal justice and related fields, allowing for more targeted recruitment while maintaining reasonable access for interested students. For prospective applicants, this selectivity level suggests that strong academic performance and demonstrated interest in criminal justice or public safety careers will significantly improve admission prospects. Students should view CUNY John Jay as a realistic option rather than a reach school, particularly those with SAT scores in the 1000-1250 range and genuine interest in law enforcement or forensic science career paths.
A directional estimate — not a prediction
Admitted students at CUNY John Jay typically score between 1000-1250 on the SAT, with a median of 1140. The middle 50% range indicates that most enrolled students fall within this band, though students scoring outside this range are admitted in smaller numbers. SAT Math scores typically range from 480-610, while SAT Verbal scores span 520-640. These ranges reflect solid academic preparation suitable for specialized criminal justice coursework and analytical thinking required in law enforcement fields. Compared to peer institutions with a median SAT of 1198, CUNY John Jay enrolls students with slightly lower test scores but within a competitive range for public colleges. The 58-point difference versus peers reflects the institution's commitment to serving students who may not have had access to extensive test preparation but demonstrate capability for success in criminal justice studies. Students scoring at or above 1140 should feel academically competitive for admission, while those below 1000 may face greater challenges but should not be automatically discouraged. The institution's strong outcomes for students across the SAT range suggest effective support systems regardless of initial test performance. Prospective students should consider whether their academic profile aligns with this range when building their college application strategy.
Understanding institutional priorities and student support
CUNY John Jay enrolls a diverse student body that reflects its urban public mission and criminal justice focus. The institution serves 59.2% Pell-eligible students, indicating strong enrollment of students from lower-income families who qualify for federal need-based aid. First-generation college students comprise 48.5% of enrollment, demonstrating the institution's effectiveness in serving families without prior college experience. Transfer students represent 38.7% of the student body, reflecting the institution's role in providing pathways for students who begin their education elsewhere or return to college after workforce experience. This composition suggests that CUNY John Jay prioritizes access and opportunity alongside academic preparation, creating a student community with diverse backgrounds and life experiences. The high Pell share indicates that financial need does not preclude admission, while the substantial first-generation enrollment suggests strong support systems for students navigating college independently. The significant transfer population reflects flexibility in serving students with varied educational pathways, including those who discover their interest in criminal justice after beginning college elsewhere. For prospective students, these demographics indicate a supportive environment for students from diverse economic and educational backgrounds, particularly those seeking second chances or non-traditional pathways into higher education.
Given CUNY John Jay's 57% acceptance rate, most qualified applicants should consider it a realistic option rather than a reach. However, students seeking alternatives should explore the options below.
Strong options in your region with comparable outcomes.
Students who enroll at CUNY John Jay demonstrate solid persistence and completion rates, though with room for improvement compared to more selective institutions. The retention rate reaches 81.3%, meaning approximately 4 out of 5 freshmen return for sophomore year. This compares to a peer median retention rate of 83.7%, indicating slightly lower persistence than similar institutions. The six-year graduation rate reaches 55.5%, while Pell-eligible students graduate at 52.2%, creating a 3.3 percentage point gap between overall and Pell completion rates. This relatively small gap suggests adequate support systems for lower-income students, though both populations face completion challenges that reflect the realities of serving first-generation and working students in an urban environment. The completion rates, while below national averages for four-year institutions, align with expectations for colleges serving diverse populations with complex life circumstances. Many students balance work, family responsibilities, and financial pressures while pursuing their education. Prospective students should understand that success at CUNY John Jay requires commitment and effective time management, particularly for those facing economic challenges or family obligations. The institution provides pathways to completion, but students must actively engage with support services and maintain academic focus despite external pressures that may impact their educational journey.
Similar quality tier in Northeast (#2100 ranked)
Schools with comparable admission profiles — useful for building a balanced list.
Higher acceptance rates with similar career outcomes.
Similar quality tier (#1071 ranked)
Similar quality tier (#1070 ranked)
Similar quality tier (#2102 ranked)
Similar quality tier (#2103 ranked)
Similar quality tier (#2104 ranked)
Build a balanced list with schools at different selectivity and price points.
Explore More Schools