Head-to-Head Analysis
This analysis was generated using Azimuth's proprietary framework. Our data model transforms federal education data into actionable insights. Learn about founder Daniel Rogers, explore our research methodology, or see how we think about this data.
Updated January 2026 • Northfield, MN & Collegeville, MN
When students choose between Carleton College and Saint John's University, they're comparing two distinct educational philosophies in Minnesota. Carleton operates as a highly selective liberal arts institution accepting just 22% of applicants, while Saint John's maintains broad access with a 90% acceptance rate.
Both schools produce graduates earning around $76,000 at the median ten years out, but the paths they offer — and who they serve — differ dramatically.
Median Student Debt at Graduation
$16,750
federal loans
$27,000
federal loans
Median Parent PLUS Loans
$31,271
borrowed by parents
$32,000
borrowed by parents
Carleton emphasizes liberal arts breadth with 16% of graduates in Social Sciences, 11% in Arts, and 10% in STEM fields. The largest programs include Computer Science (71 graduates), Biology (61), and International Relations (48).
Saint John's concentrates on professional preparation with 31% of graduates in Business fields and 16% in Social Sciences. Their top programs are Business Administration (62 graduates), Accounting (59), and Economics (33).
These different program mixes reflect distinct institutional missions but yield comparable earning outcomes.
For students prioritizing financial outcomes, both schools deliver comparable earnings at similar costs — the choice comes down to fit and completion risk. Carleton offers a prestigious liberal arts experience with lower debt and higher graduation rates, making it ideal for academically strong students who can gain admission.
Saint John's provides broad access and strong business programs, serving students who might not qualify for highly selective schools. The data slightly favors Carleton due to lower debt levels and superior completion rates, but Saint John's accomplishes remarkable outcomes for its more accessible student population.
Your decision should center on admissions probability and preferred campus culture.
Key Takeaway
The numbers are close, but the best school depends on your goals, values, and career aspirations.
This comparison was generated using Azimuth's proprietary ROI framework, developed by founder Daniel Rogers. Our methodology transforms federal education data into actionable insights for families.
This comparison uses Azimuth's proprietary ROI model based on U.S. Dept. of Education data. View Full Methodology.
This content is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, investment, or professional advice. Consult a qualified advisor before making any financial decisions.
College Azimuth is a private research initiative and is not affiliated with the U.S. Department of Education or Federal Student Aid.
