Head-to-Head Analysis
This analysis was generated using Azimuth's proprietary framework. Our data model transforms federal education data into actionable insights. Learn about founder Daniel Rogers, explore our research methodology, or see how we think about this data.
Updated January 2026 • Helena, MT & Redding, CA
When students choose between Simpson University and Carroll College, they're comparing two small private colleges with fundamentally different approaches to student success. Both offer the intimate campus experience typical of small liberal arts institutions, but the outcomes data reveals a striking pattern: Simpson achieves results that exceed expectations while serving a more economically diverse student population, while Carroll underperforms predictions despite serving more affluent students.
The question becomes: which institutional model better serves your goals?
Median Student Debt at Graduation
$25,757
federal loans
$18,750
federal loans
Median Parent PLUS Loans
$37,513
borrowed by parents
$19,112
borrowed by parents
Simpson is predominantly Psychology-focused, with top programs including Psychology (59 graduates), Business Administration (45), and Registered Nursing (35). The program mix shows 21% Business concentration.
Carroll emphasizes Health fields, with Registered Nursing (38 graduates), Biology (32), and Health Sciences (28) leading enrollment. Carroll's mix includes 15% Business and 7% Social Sciences.
These different academic emphases help explain career trajectory differences, though both institutions offer nursing programs that feed into healthcare markets.
For students prioritizing institutional effectiveness and manageable debt, Simpson delivers superior value-added outcomes while creating less financial stress. The school achieves remarkable results — earnings $8,849 beyond expectations — while serving a more economically diverse population.
Carroll offers higher raw earnings and better completion rates, making it the better choice for students confident in graduation and comfortable with higher debt levels. The data points to Simpson as the stronger institutional performer, but the right choice depends on your completion confidence, debt tolerance, and career priorities.
If you value schools that elevate all students regardless of background, Simpson demonstrates exceptional effectiveness.
Key Takeaway
The numbers are close, but the best school depends on your goals, values, and career aspirations.
This comparison was generated using Azimuth's proprietary ROI framework, developed by founder Daniel Rogers. Our methodology transforms federal education data into actionable insights for families.
This comparison uses Azimuth's proprietary ROI model based on U.S. Dept. of Education data. View Full Methodology.
This content is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, investment, or professional advice. Consult a qualified advisor before making any financial decisions.
College Azimuth is a private research initiative and is not affiliated with the U.S. Department of Education or Federal Student Aid.
