SUNY Geneseo admits approximately 63.5% of applicants, meaning roughly 2 in 3 applicants receive offers of admission. This places the institution in the moderately selective category, significantly more accessible than highly selective private colleges but more competitive than typical public institutions. The peer median admission rate of 84.6% highlights Geneseo's relative selectivity within the public sector, with acceptance rates 21 percentage points lower than similar institutions. This selectivity level reflects the college's academic reputation and strong outcomes within the SUNY system. Students should expect meaningful competition for admission, particularly from high-achieving in-state applicants drawn to the liberal arts focus and relatively low cost. The admission process requires solid academic preparation, though the majority of qualified applicants do receive offers. For prospective students, this selectivity suggests Geneseo should be considered a target school for well-prepared students rather than a safety option, requiring backup plans with higher acceptance rates.
A directional estimate — not a prediction
Admitted students at SUNY Geneseo demonstrate exceptional academic preparation, with SAT scores ranging from 1200-1380 and a median of 1296. The middle 50% of enrolled students fall within this range, though students scoring outside these bounds are admitted in smaller numbers. SAT Math scores typically range from 590-690, while Verbal scores span 610-690, showing balanced strength across subjects. ACT scores range from 26-31 with a median of 28, placing admitted students well above national averages. These test scores significantly exceed peer institution medians, with SAT scores 206 points higher than typical for similar public colleges. Students scoring below 1200 SAT or 26 ACT should expect to be at a competitive disadvantage but are not automatically excluded from consideration. The academic profile indicates that successful applicants typically rank in the top quartile of their high school classes, though the institution evaluates applications holistically. Prospective students should consider whether their academic credentials align with these ranges when building their college lists, treating Geneseo as a reach if scores fall significantly below the 25th percentile markers.
Understanding institutional priorities and student support
SUNY Geneseo enrolls 25.4% Pell-eligible students and 18.6% first-generation students, indicating the institution serves a mix of economic backgrounds while maintaining selective academic standards. The Pell share demonstrates that approximately 1 in 4 students comes from lower-income families, though this proportion is lower than at many public institutions. First-generation students represent nearly 1 in 5 enrolled students, suggesting the college successfully attracts students whose parents did not attend college. The transfer share of 15.6% indicates that most students enter as first-year students, with limited spots available for transfer applicants. These demographic patterns reflect Geneseo's positioning as a selective public institution that attracts academically prepared students from diverse backgrounds, though with somewhat limited economic diversity compared to more accessible public colleges. Students from lower-income families should know that 25.4% of enrolled students share their background, while first-generation students can expect to find 18.6% of peers in similar circumstances.
Given SUNY Geneseo's 63.5% acceptance rate and high academic standards, many qualified students will need alternative options. The schools below offer similar outcomes with different admission profiles or advantages.
Strong options in your region with comparable outcomes.
SUNY Geneseo demonstrates solid retention and completion outcomes, with 83.8% of freshmen returning for sophomore year compared to a peer median of 73.2%. The graduation rate reaches 72.1%, significantly above the peer median of 49.3% and indicating strong institutional support for degree completion. Pell-eligible students graduate at 63.3%, creating an 8.8 percentage point gap compared to the overall completion rate. This Pell gap is notable and suggests some challenges for lower-income students in completing their degrees, though the absolute completion rate for Pell students remains above many institutional averages. The retention and completion patterns indicate that students who gain admission can expect strong institutional support, though lower-income students may face additional challenges. Prospective students should view the 83.8% retention rate as an indicator of academic rigor combined with adequate support systems, while the Pell completion gap signals the importance of utilizing available resources for students from lower-income backgrounds.
Similar quality tier in Northeast (#387 ranked)
Schools with comparable admission profiles — useful for building a balanced list.
Higher acceptance rates with similar career outcomes.
Similar quality tier (#390 ranked)
Similar quality tier (#389 ranked)
Similar quality tier (#395 ranked)
Similar quality tier (#383 ranked)
Similar quality tier (#401 ranked)
Build a balanced list with schools at different selectivity and price points.
Explore More Schools