Percentile rankings vs 1,600+ peer institutions. Higher is better.
Career OutcomesAzimuth ranks The College of Idaho #1182 for overall value on Azimuth's composite among nonprofit four-year institutions. Graduates earn about $13,508 less than similar students at comparable institutions, placing The College of Idaho in the 13.0 percentile for earnings beyond expectations among nonprofit four-year institutions. Azimuth ranks The College of Idaho #1214 for return on investment among nonprofit four-year institutions. --- The College of Idaho's composite ranking reflects balanced strength across Azimuth's pillars of return, access, and mobility. The institution earns about $13,508 less than similar students at comparable institutions, demonstrating consistent outcomes relative to peer institutions.
Azimuth ranks The College of Idaho #1182 for overall value on Azimuth's composite among nonprofit four-year institutions — in the 19.9 percentile for overall value on Azimuth's composite among nonprofit four-year institutions. A private baccalaureate college in Caldwell, Idaho, College of Idaho enrolls roughly 1,041 undergraduates. Retention is 81.8% and the six-year graduation rate is 62.5%, reflecting solid completion outcomes for a residential liberal arts institution. Where The College of Idaho performs strongest is return on investment. Azimuth ranks The College of Idaho #1214 for return on investment among nonprofit four-year institutions — in the 18.0 percentile for return on investment among nonprofit four-year institutions. Graduates earn median 4-year earnings of $52,628, placing The College of Idaho in the 12.5 percentile for median earnings four years after enrollment among nonprofit four-year institutions. The institution's dominant program family is Business, which aligns with strong labor-market demand and contributes to solid early-career earnings trajectories for graduates. Access and affordability sit lower in the composite. The College of Idaho enrolls 25.2% Pell-eligible students and 26.8% first-generation college students, reflecting a more selective admissions posture typical of private baccalaureate colleges. The College of Idaho sits in the 30.5 percentile for access and the 46.8 percentile for affordability among nonprofit four-year institutions. For admitted students, the institution's financial aid and net-price positioning merit exploration through the Financial GPS tool to understand scenario-specific affordability by major and family income.
The College of Idaho's published cost of attendance is $50,542. Need-based financial aid reshapes that figure across income levels: low-income families pay approximately $14,026, middle-income families pay around $17,773, and higher-income families pay approximately $23,095. Azimuth ranks The College of Idaho #759 for post-graduation affordability among nonprofit four-year institutions. Net prices by income band are medians within those bands; individual aid packages vary, so some families in each band pay more and some less than the figures shown. The College of Idaho participates in federal (Pell Grants, Direct Loans), state, and institutional aid programs. Families apply for need-based aid using the FAFSA, and the institution evaluates demonstrated financial need to construct aid packages combining grants, loans, and work-study opportunities. The gap between published cost of attendance and net price reflects the institution's commitment to need-based aid, though the specific aid structure and percentage of need met vary by individual family circumstances. Median federal student loan debt at graduation is $24,500, and families using Parent PLUS borrow a median of $32,427; private or institutional loans may add further borrowing that falls outside these federal-only figures — see the Parent PLUS risk framework for how household context shapes PLUS decisions. For a graduate at the institution's median four-year earnings of $52,628, median federal debt of $24,500 projects to a monthly payment of about $277 under standard ten-year repayment. For personalized projections across earnings scenarios — including Parent PLUS planning — use Azimuth's Financial GPS tool.
The College of Idaho is a strong fit for students seeking a private liberal arts education in ID, particularly those interested in Business and related fields. Its small size and focused academic environment appeal to students who prefer personalized attention while still accessing strong career outcomes. Graduates earn median 4-year earnings of $52,628, placing The College of Idaho in the 12.5 percentile for median earnings four years after enrollment among nonprofit four-year institutions. They earn about $13,508 less than similar students at comparable institutions, placing the institution in the 13.0 percentile for earnings beyond expectations among nonprofit four-year institutions. The college serves a mix of traditional and non-traditional students, with 25.2% of undergraduates receiving Pell Grants and 26.8% being first-generation. This combination of access and outcomes makes it particularly compelling for students from modest backgrounds seeking upward mobility in West's job market. Fit depends on two realistic filters: the 49.1% admit rate makes admission selective, and the Business-heavy program mix (24% of degrees) favors certain academic interests. Students aligned with these priorities will find one of ID's strongest private college options.
This school profile was generated using Azimuth's proprietary ROI framework, developed by founder Daniel Rogers. Our methodology transforms federal education data into actionable insights for families.
College Azimuth is a private research initiative and is not affiliated with the U.S. Department of Education or Federal Student Aid. Data sourced from College Scorecard.
This content is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, investment, or professional advice. Consult a qualified advisor before making any financial decisions.
Comprehensive Analysis
Detailed metrics, charts, and full data breakdown
Financial GPS Tool
Personalized cost and earnings calculator
This is the The College Of Idaho hub overview page. Related admissions, cost, outcomes, majors, and similar-school pages provide the detailed school data.
Based on federal data for students receiving aid. Actual costs may vary.
The College of Idaho's published cost of attendance is $50,542. Need-based financial aid reshapes that figure across income levels: low-income families pay approximately $14,026, middle-income families pay around $17,773, and higher-income families pay approximately $23,095.
Azimuth ranks The College of Idaho #759 for post-graduation affordability among nonprofit four-year institutions. Net prices by income band are medians within those bands; individual aid packages vary, so some families in each band pay more and some less than the figures shown.
The College of Idaho participates in federal (Pell Grants, Direct Loans), state, and institutional aid programs. Families apply for need-based aid using the FAFSA, and the institution evaluates demonstrated financial need to construct aid packages combining grants, loans, and work-study opportunities.
The gap between published cost of attendance and net price reflects the institution's commitment to need-based aid, though the specific aid structure and percentage of need met vary by individual family circumstances. Median federal student loan debt at graduation is $24,500, and families using Parent PLUS borrow a median of $32,427; private or institutional loans may add further borrowing that falls outside these federal-only figures — see the [Parent PLUS risk framework](/analysis/ou-what-happens-when-parents-borrow-too/) for how household context shapes PLUS decisions.
For a graduate at the institution's median four-year earnings of $52,628, median federal debt of $24,500 projects to a monthly payment of about $277 under standard ten-year repayment. For personalized projections across earnings scenarios — including Parent PLUS planning — use [Azimuth's Financial GPS tool](/analysis/financial-gps-framework/).
Graduates of the College of Idaho earn median 4-year earnings of $52,628, placing The College of Idaho in the 12.5 percentile for median earnings four years after enrollment among nonprofit four-year institutions. The College of Idaho sits in the 13.0 percentile for [earnings beyond expectations](/analysis/a-value-added-approach-to-college-outcomes/) among nonprofit four-year institutions.
Azimuth ranks The College of Idaho #1214 for return on investment among nonprofit four-year institutions. The program lineup anchors on Business Administration, which enrolls 50 graduates earning median 4-year earnings of $60,094 — 0.9× the national benchmark for the field [per the program-ranking methodology](/analysis/college-program-rankings-how-to-actually-evaluate-programs/).
Biology, General follows with 42 graduates earning $47,149, and Psychology, General with 30 graduates earning $54,179. Together, these programs form the economic core of the institution's degree output, supported by Kinesiology and International Relations and National Security Studies, which round out the top-earning portfolio.
Business Administration, Management and Operations
50 graduates
Psychology, General
30 graduates
Biology, General
42 graduates
History
10 graduates
Natural Resources Conservation and Research
8 graduates
The College of Idaho's program mix is anchored in business and professional fields, reflecting the institution's identity as a private liberal arts college with applied career focus. Business Administration is the largest program with 50 graduates, followed by Biology, General with 42 graduates, Psychology, General with 30 graduates, Kinesiology with 24 graduates, and International Relations and National Security Studies with 14 graduates.
Across 13 programs, 0 meet Azimuth's ranking threshold, serving roughly 235 students annually. The strongest earnings outcomes cluster in applied business and professional fields.
Business Administration leads with median 4-year earnings of $60,094, followed by Psychology, General with median earnings of $54,179, and Biology, General with median earnings of $47,149. This earnings concentration reflects The College of Idaho's strength in Business and related professional disciplines, where graduates enter the workforce directly into stable, in-demand roles.
The program portfolio emphasizes practical skill development and employer alignment over research-intensive pathways, a positioning that supports early-career earnings and labor-market entry. The College of Idaho's program signature — concentrated in Business at 24%, Social Sciences at 11%, and Arts at 7% — aligns with regional employer demand and career pathways where graduates can establish themselves quickly.
Explore alternatives with comparable outcomes based on location, selectivity, and value:
| School | State | Accept Rate | Median Earnings | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Northwest Nazarene University Higher acceptance rate (15.7 percentage points higher) with similar program focus and located 8 miles away; similar graduate earnings | ID | 63% | $51,719 | Compare |
Boise State University Higher acceptance rate (36.7 percentage points higher) and located 24 miles away; similar graduate earnings | ID | 84% | $51,658 | Compare |
Corban University Higher acceptance rate (42.5 percentage points higher) with similar program focus; similar graduate earnings | OR | 90% | $48,917 | Compare |
Southern Oregon University Higher acceptance rate (35.4 percentage points higher) with similar program focus; similar graduate earnings | OR | 83% | $49,175 | Compare |
Northwest Nazarene University Same state (8 miles away) with similar earnings and similar program focus; same institution type | ID | 63% | $51,719 | Compare |
Peer institutions with comparable quality and outcomes:
| School | State | Accept Rate | Median Earnings | Rank | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bridgewater College Similar quality tier (#32776 ranked) | VA | 92% | $53,453 | #32776 | Compare |
Illinois College Similar quality tier (#32778 ranked) | IL | 78% | $52,575 | #32778 | Compare |
Florida Southern College Similar quality tier (#32779 ranked) | FL | 64% | $55,294 | #32779 | Compare |
Baptist University Of Florida Similar quality tier (#32781 ranked) | FL | 36% | $42,836 | #32781 | Compare |
Livingstone College Similar quality tier (#32768 ranked) | NC | 59% | $32,600 | #32768 | Compare |